Prior authorization, payer by payer: what the first public reports show

What the first prior authorization reports from California's Medicare Advantage and Medi-Cal plans show, and which of them can be compared.

By Tyler Kent15-minute read

Health plans had to post their first prior authorization reports by March 31, 2026, covering 2025. Among the California reports that pass a basic like-for-like test, most denied 3% or less of standard requests: 19 of 27 Medicare Advantage reports and 10 of 15 Medi-Cal managed care reports, by Kent Applied's count from the plans' own reports. Weighted by members, as KFF weights its national figures, those reports denied 9.2% of standard requests in Medicare Advantage and 3.0% in Medi-Cal. Nationally, KFF found 12% for Medicare Advantage and 14% for Medicaid managed care.

Prior authorization is the process by which a provider gets a plan's approval before providing care, and a standard request is one for a service that is not urgent. In the comparable reports, the share of standard requests denied ran from 0.9% to 19.5% in Medicare Advantage and from 0.64% to 8.95% in Medi-Cal managed care. The weighted Medicare Advantage figure is far above the middle report's 2.0% because the largest contracts denied more: 58% of members in the comparable reports were in reports that denied 10% or more.

Some reports can't be compared at all, and the rest only on a generous reading, because the federal rule says which numbers plans must post but not how to count them. Of the 59 plan reports in this dataset, six say how they count a request that was partly approved, and four say whether their denials include administrative ones, such as duplicate requests. This report shows every number as the plan posted it and says how each report counted.

Fig. 1

Most comparable California plan reports denied 3% or less of standard requests in 2025

Share of standard (non-urgent) prior authorization requests denied in 2025, one dot per report, among the reports that pass a basic like-for-like test: Medicare Advantage contracts mostly in California, and Medi-Cal managed care plans

Show the numbers as a table
Most comparable California plan reports denied 3% or less of standard requests in 2025
ItemGroupValueNote
Anthem Blue Cross H4471Medicare Advantage0.9%Posted as a percentage only
Central Health Plan of California H5649Medicare Advantage1.0%Posted as a percentage only
L.A. Care Health Plan H1224Medicare Advantage1.03%2,935 of 284,406 standard requests
Blue Shield of California H2819Medicare Advantage1.31%1,617 of 122,926 standard requests
CalOptima Health H5433Medicare Advantage1.38%1,311 of 94,832 standard requests
Blue Shield of California H5928Medicare Advantage1.50%1,010 of 67,137 standard requests
Blue Shield of California H0504Medicare Advantage1.54%6,934 of 451,021 standard requests
Anthem Blue Cross H0544Medicare Advantage1.6%Posted as a percentage only
SCAN Health Plan (Medicare Advantage)Medicare Advantage1.85%38,284 of 2,070,236 standard requests
Wellcare By Health Net H0562Medicare Advantage1.94%3,584 of 184,541 standard requests
Wellcare By Health Net H3561Medicare Advantage1.98%5,737 of 290,257 standard requests
Molina Healthcare of California H3038Medicare Advantage2.0%Posted as a percentage only
Molina Healthcare of California H5810Medicare Advantage2.0%Posted as a percentage only
Aetna H4982Medicare Advantage2.04%Posted as a percentage only
Alignment Health Plan H3815Medicare Advantage2.14%17,933 of 837,729 standard requests
Anthem Blue Cross H4161Medicare Advantage2.2%Posted as a percentage only
Aetna H0523Medicare Advantage2.39%Posted as a percentage only
Alignment Health Plan H4961Medicare Advantage2.88%146 of 5,063 standard requests
Alignment Health Plan H8832Medicare Advantage2.89%117 of 4,044 standard requests
Anthem Blue Cross H8552Medicare Advantage5.0%Posted as a percentage only
Anthem Blue Cross H4704Medicare Advantage9.2%Posted as a percentage only
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Northern California)Medicare Advantage10.53%15,214 of 144,514 standard requests
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Southern California)Medicare Advantage10.95%3,706 of 33,855 standard requests
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Northern California)Medicare Advantage11.33%4,486 of 39,581 standard requests
Blue Shield of California H4937Medicare Advantage12.04%461 of 3,829 standard requests
Aetna H5309Medicare Advantage16.34%Posted as a percentage only
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California)Medicare Advantage19.48%27,992 of 143,690 standard requests
Community Health Group (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care0.64%Posted as a percentage only
Blue Shield of California Promise Health Plan (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care0.67%6,003 of 892,009 standard requests
Central California Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care1.55%8,029 of 518,170 standard requests
CalOptima Health (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care1.72%16,568 of 965,191 standard requests
L.A. Care Health Plan (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care1.86%40,033 of 2,152,883 standard requests
Gold Coast Health Plan (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care1.96%6,245 of 319,137 standard requests
Molina Healthcare of California (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care2.0%Posted as a percentage only
Health Net (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care2.45%75,814 of 3,096,168 standard requests
Anthem Blue Cross (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care2.6%Posted as a percentage only
Alameda Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care2.97%3,485 of 117,421 standard requests
Health Plan of San Joaquin (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care5.03%Posted as a percentage only
CalViva Health (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care6.34%19,665 of 310,319 standard requests
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Southern California)Medi-Cal managed care6.39%3,622 of 56,689 standard requests
Community Health Plan of Imperial Valley (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care7.57%4,347 of 57,406 standard requests
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Northern California)Medi-Cal managed care8.95%2,235 of 24,982 standard requests

What did the federal rule make plans post?

Every Medicare Advantage organization and Medi-Cal managed care plan must post nine prior authorization items on its own website by March 31 each year, covering the year before. The requirement comes from CMS's Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule, published on February 8, 2024. It covers Medicare Advantage organizations, state Medicaid and CHIP fee-for-service programs, Medicaid managed care plans, CHIP managed care entities, and insurers that sell plans on the federally facilitated exchanges, which CMS calls "impacted payers." The first reports, for 2025, were due March 31, 2026.

The nine items, as 42 CFR 422.122(c) lists them for Medicare Advantage and 438.210(f) repeats them for Medicaid managed care plans:

  1. A list of all items and services that require prior authorization.
  2. The percentage of standard requests that were approved.
  3. The percentage of standard requests that were denied.
  4. The percentage of standard requests that were approved after appeal.
  5. The percentage of requests for which the time to decide was extended, and the request was approved.
  6. The percentage of expedited requests that were approved.
  7. The percentage of expedited requests that were denied.
  8. The average and median time from request to decision for standard requests.
  9. The average and median time from request to decision for expedited requests.

Medicare Advantage organizations report for each contract they hold with CMS, and one company can hold several. Medi-Cal managed care plans report for the whole plan, and the state reports for Medi-Cal fee-for-service.

Covered California's plans are outside the rule. The rule's marketplace sections apply only to issuers on the federally facilitated exchanges, and California runs its own exchange, which CMS lists among the state-based exchanges for plan year 2026.

In 2025, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care plans had to decide standard requests within 14 calendar days and expedited requests within 72 hours. For Medicaid managed care plans, 14 days was the federal cap on the time frames each state sets. Three Medi-Cal plans' reports give California's limit for standard requests in 2025 as 5 business days. From January 1, 2026, the rule cuts the standard limit to seven calendar days, so the second reports, due March 31, 2027, will cover the first year under the shorter limit.

9

prior authorization items a Medicare Advantage organization must post each year for the year before, by March 31

Since 2026, each Medicare Advantage contract must post nine prior authorization items for the previous year on its organization's website by March 31, under 42 CFR 422.122(c).

Source: eCFR, 42 CFR 422.122(c), Publicly reporting prior authorization metrics.

KentAppliedkentapplied.com/facts/prior-auth-metrics-due-march-31

How much of California do the posted reports cover?

Posted reports cover 94.9% of California's Medicare Advantage members and 95.8% of its Medi-Cal managed care members, counted by enrollment in December 2025. The Medicare Advantage figure comes from 37 of the 40 contracts in the dataset, which the method below describes. The Medi-Cal figure comes from 20 of the 24 managed care plans in the state's enrollment report. A report counts as posted when it is on the site of the plan or of its parent company (for Medicare Advantage, the parent CMS lists for the contract), whatever date it went up, and some went up after March 31, 2026. The reports of CalViva Health and Community Health Plan of Imperial Valley count too, because each carries the plan's own name, although both sit on Health Net's site.

Eight of the Medicare Advantage contracts with a posted report have most of their members in other states, so their reports mostly describe people outside California. Together they held 12.8% of California's Medicare Advantage members, and their reports can't be split by state, so they stay out of the California comparisons below.

For Medi-Cal, no 2025 report could be found on the sites of two plans, Kern Family Health Care and Health Plan of San Mateo, with about 540,000 members between them. SCAN Health Plan posts one report with no separate Medi-Cal figures, and Health Plan of San Joaquin's report doesn't say whether it includes Mountain Valley Health Plan. Not found means not found in a search of the plan's own site, a weaker finding than not posted.

Fig. 2

Posted reports cover 95% of California Medicare Advantage and 96% of Medi-Cal plan members

Share of California enrollment in December 2025 by what each plan posted for 2025: Medicare Advantage (3.66 million members) and Medi-Cal managed care (13.7 million)

Show the numbers as a table
Posted reports cover 95% of California Medicare Advantage and 96% of Medi-Cal plan members
CategoryReport postedReport posted, contract mostly outside CaliforniaNo separate report foundSmaller contracts, not checked
Medicare Advantage, 3.66 million members82.02%12.84%1.07%4.07%
Medi-Cal managed care, 13.7 million members95.84%0.0%4.16%0.0%

How do California's reports compare with the national figures?

Weighted the way KFF weights its figures, the comparable California reports came in below the national averages, at 9.2% in Medicare Advantage and 3.0% in Medi-Cal. KFF found that Medicare Advantage insurers denied 12% of standard requests in 2025, Medicaid managed care insurers 14% and insurers in the federally facilitated Marketplace 18%. It collected the reports of the largest insurers in each market, 14 insurers in all.

Counted one report at a time, 24 of the 27 Medicare Advantage reports and all 15 Medi-Cal reports were below KFF's figure for their market. The weighting is rough, because KFF weights large insurers nationally at the parent company level, while this report weights California contracts and plans and splits a contract reported in two regional parts by each part's share of the requests.

Fig. 3

Insurers denied 12% to 18% of standard prior authorization requests in 2025, KFF found

Share of standard (non-urgent) prior authorization requests denied in 2025, by market, in the reports of the largest insurers in each, weighted by enrollment

Show the numbers as a table
Insurers denied 12% to 18% of standard prior authorization requests in 2025, KFF found
CategoryValue
Medicare Advantage12%
Medicaid managed care14%
Federally facilitated Marketplace18%

Why can't the posted numbers be ranked as they stand?

Plans counted different things, and the rule leaves the counting to them. CMS had published an optional example template, and several reports dated March 2026 already follow its layout. In July 2026, after the first reports were due, it published an updated version that says what each share should count and what it should be out of, and that version says the template "is not required." Four differences change the posted numbers.

The first is partly approved requests, which three reports say they count as denied, two count as approved and one counts separately as "modified." The other 53 reports don't say, so the same decision could land in either column.

The second is administrative denials. Partnership HealthPlan of California (Medi-Cal) posted the highest denial share among Medi-Cal plans, 22.34% of standard requests. Its report says those denials include administrative ones, such as duplicate requests or requests for services that need no authorization, and it splits them out: 7.21% of its standard requests were denied for medical necessity and 15.13% were administrative. Among Medicare Advantage reports, UnitedHealthcare's three say the requests they did not approve include administrative reasons too, such as missing medical documents. The rest don't say.

Fig. 4

Two-thirds of Partnership HealthPlan of California's standard denials were administrative

Standard prior authorization requests in 2025 at Partnership HealthPlan of California, a Medi-Cal plan with 896,522 members in December 2025, as its report counts them. Administrative denials include duplicate requests and requests for services that need no authorization

Show the numbers as a table
Two-thirds of Partnership HealthPlan of California's standard denials were administrative
FromToValue
Standard requestsApproved264,936 requests
Standard requestsDenied76,228 requests
DeniedDenied for medical necessity24,607 requests
DeniedDenied for administrative reasons51,621 requests

The third is what the appeal share is out of. CMS's template divides approvals after appeal by appeals, and so do most reports that say. CalOptima Health (Medi-Cal) posted 28.33% (306 of 1,080 appeals). L.A. Care Health Plan (Medi-Cal) posted 0.01% (165 of 2,112,850 approvals), because it divided by all of its approvals rather than by its appeals.

The fourth is what the extension share is out of. A plan may take extra time to decide in some cases, and the template divides the requests approved after that extra time by all requests. Instead, 17 reports divided by the requests they extended, and two more appear to, though their column is labeled as requests. Blue Shield of California H0504 posted 77%, 135 of the 176 standard requests it extended; out of all 451,021 of its standard requests, that is 0.03%.

Anthem Blue Cross's seven reports gave times as whole numbers with no unit, with a footnote saying a 1 means up to 24 hours. 17 other reports posted a standard median of "0 days," which can mean anything under a day. CMS's July template now says medians under a day "must be reported in hours rather than rounded to '0 days.'"

Fig. 5

Few 2025 reports say how they counted partial approvals or administrative denials

Share of the 2025 prior authorization reports posted by plans serving California that state each of these, by program. Medi-Cal fee-for-service, the state's one report, is not shown

Show the numbers as a table
Few 2025 reports say how they counted partial approvals or administrative denials
What the report statesProgramValueNote
Gives countsMedicare Advantage (38 reports)63.16%24 of 38 reports
Gives countsMedi-Cal managed care (21 reports)80.95%17 of 21 reports
Says how partial approvals countMedicare Advantage (38 reports)5.26%2 of 38 reports
Says how partial approvals countMedi-Cal managed care (21 reports)19.05%4 of 21 reports
Says whether administrative denials countMedicare Advantage (38 reports)7.89%3 of 38 reports
Says whether administrative denials countMedi-Cal managed care (21 reports)4.76%1 of 21 reports
Names the appeal totalMedicare Advantage (38 reports)55.26%21 of 38 reports
Names the appeal totalMedi-Cal managed care (21 reports)57.14%12 of 21 reports
Names the extension totalMedicare Advantage (38 reports)63.16%24 of 38 reports
Names the extension totalMedi-Cal managed care (21 reports)85.71%18 of 21 reports
Gives a unit for timesMedicare Advantage (38 reports)81.58%31 of 38 reports
Gives a unit for timesMedi-Cal managed care (21 reports)90.48%19 of 21 reports
Posts all eight figuresMedicare Advantage (38 reports)73.68%28 of 38 reports
Posts all eight figuresMedi-Cal managed care (21 reports)95.24%20 of 21 reports

Which reports can be compared, and what do they show?

In Medicare Advantage, 27 of the 30 reports from contracts mostly in California can be compared with one another, and in Medi-Cal managed care, 15 of the 21 reports can. Each counts as posted, its approved and denied shares account for every standard request, and it doesn't say it counts partly approved requests or administrative denials differently from the rest. Denial shares from Medicare Advantage and Medi-Cal reports are never compared with each other, because, as KFF notes, how sick members are and which services they use "likely vary substantially between lines of business."

In the comparable Medicare Advantage reports, the share of standard requests denied ran from 0.9% at Anthem Blue Cross H4471 to 19.5% at Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California), and the middle report denied 2.0%. Six reports were at 10% or more. Four of those six come from Kaiser Permanente's two contracts that each report Northern and Southern California separately.

For Medi-Cal, the share ran from 0.64% at Community Health Group (Medi-Cal) to 8.95% at Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Northern California), and none reached 10%. These shares are Kent Applied's where a plan posted counts, worked out the way CMS's template expects; elsewhere they are the plan's own percentages.

29 of 42

comparable 2025 prior authorization reports from plans serving California that denied 3% or less of standard requests

29 of the 42 California prior authorization reports that pass a basic like-for-like test denied 3% or less of standard requests in 2025: 19 of 27 in Medicare Advantage and 10 of 15 in Medi-Cal managed care, by Kent Applied's count.

Source: Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset).

KentAppliedkentapplied.com/facts/prior-auth-comparable-reports-3-percent-or-less-2025

Were urgent requests denied more often than standard ones?

Expedited requests, the urgent ones, were denied more often than standard ones at 9 of the 16 comparable Medicare Advantage reports that posted counts for both kinds of request, and at 5 of 11 Medi-Cal reports. KFF's national averages show expedited requests denied less often: 10% against 12% of standard ones in Medicare Advantage, and 12% against 14% in Medicaid managed care.

At single plans the gap can be wide. Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California) denied 19.48% of standard requests and 3.65% of expedited ones.

Fig. 6

Urgent requests were denied more often than standard ones at 9 of 16 Medicare Advantage reports

Share of standard (non-urgent) and expedited (urgent) prior authorization requests denied in 2025, computed from each plan's posted counts, among the reports that pass a basic like-for-like test. Each row is one plan's report, named as the plan names it

Show the numbers as a table
Urgent requests were denied more often than standard ones at 9 of 16 Medicare Advantage reports
CategoryStandardExpedited
L.A. Care Health Plan H12241.03%2.06%
Blue Shield of California H28191.31%2.78%
CalOptima Health H54331.38%1.90%
Blue Shield of California H59281.50%2.10%
Blue Shield of California H05041.54%2.43%
SCAN Health Plan (Medicare Advantage)1.85%2.21%
Wellcare By Health Net H05621.94%2.87%
Wellcare By Health Net H35611.98%3.03%
Alignment Health Plan H38152.14%2.87%
Alignment Health Plan H49612.88%1.96%
Alignment Health Plan H88322.89%2.12%
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Northern California)10.53%7.46%
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Southern California)10.95%2.80%
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Northern California)11.33%8.46%
Blue Shield of California H493712.04%2.33%
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California)19.48%3.65%
Blue Shield of California Promise Health Plan (Medi-Cal)0.67%1.07%
Central California Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal)1.55%0.29%
CalOptima Health (Medi-Cal)1.72%3.11%
L.A. Care Health Plan (Medi-Cal)1.86%3.78%
Gold Coast Health Plan (Medi-Cal)1.96%1.66%
Health Net (Medi-Cal)2.45%4.32%
Alameda Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal)2.97%4.06%
CalViva Health (Medi-Cal)6.34%5.10%
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Southern California)6.39%2.58%
Community Health Plan of Imperial Valley (Medi-Cal)7.57%3.18%
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Northern California)8.95%6.45%

How fast did plans decide?

In both programs, most usable medians were two days or less. Of the 30 Medicare Advantage reports from contracts mostly in California, 15 posted a standard median that converts to hours, and 11 of those were two days or less. Of the 21 Medi-Cal reports, 16 did, and 11 were two days or less. The rest posted "0 days," gave no unit or posted no times: 15 in Medicare Advantage and 5 in Medi-Cal.

The slowest Medi-Cal median was 6.98 days, at Health Plan of San Joaquin (Medi-Cal), so half of its standard decisions in 2025 took that long or longer. The slowest Medicare Advantage median was 6.42 days, at Santa Clara Family Health Plan H4045. KFF's national figures, which weight the largest insurers' reported medians by enrollment, put the median for standard requests at 1 day in Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care and 0.9 days in the federally facilitated Marketplace.

Within each program, plans that denied more did not reliably take longer to decide. Ranking the comparable reports by denial share and by median time gives two orders that barely agree: a rank correlation of -0.04 across 12 Medicare Advantage reports and 0.20 across 10 Medi-Cal reports, where 1 would mean the same order.

Fig. 7

Comparable reports show no clear link between denying more and deciding more slowly

Each dot is one plan's 2025 report, colored by program. It shows the share of standard (non-urgent) prior authorization requests the plan denied and its median hours from request to decision, for the reports that pass a basic like-for-like test and gave their median in a unit. The link is measured within each program

Show the numbers as a table
Comparable reports show no clear link between denying more and deciding more slowly
ItemGroupShare of standard requests deniedMedian hours from request to decisionNote
Alignment Health Plan H3815Medicare Advantage2.14%12 hoursMedian posted as 0.50 days
Alignment Health Plan H4961Medicare Advantage2.88%72 hoursMedian posted as 3.00 days
Alignment Health Plan H8832Medicare Advantage2.89%18 hoursMedian posted as 0.75 days
Blue Shield of California H4937Medicare Advantage12.04%72 hoursMedian posted in whole days
CalOptima Health H5433Medicare Advantage1.38%0 hoursMedian posted as 0.0 days
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Northern California)Medicare Advantage10.53%22 hoursMedian posted as 22 hours
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California)Medicare Advantage19.48%2 hoursMedian posted as 2 hours
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Northern California)Medicare Advantage11.33%21 hoursMedian posted as 21 hours
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Southern California)Medicare Advantage10.95%2 hoursMedian posted as 2 hours
SCAN Health Plan (Medicare Advantage)Medicare Advantage1.85%24 hoursMedian posted in whole days
Wellcare By Health Net H0562Medicare Advantage1.94%24 hoursMedian posted in whole days
Wellcare By Health Net H3561Medicare Advantage1.98%24 hoursMedian posted in whole days
Alameda Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care2.97%33.6 hoursMedian posted as 1.4 days
Blue Shield of California Promise Health Plan (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care0.67%24 hoursMedian posted in whole days
CalOptima Health (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care1.72%0 hoursMedian posted as 0.00 days
Community Health Group (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care0.64%0.02 hoursMedian posted as 0.0007 days
Community Health Plan of Imperial Valley (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care7.57%24 hoursMedian posted in whole days
Gold Coast Health Plan (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care1.96%96 hoursMedian posted in whole days
Health Plan of San Joaquin (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care5.03%167.52 hoursMedian posted as 6.98 days
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Northern California)Medi-Cal managed care8.95%21 hoursMedian posted as 21 hours
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Southern California)Medi-Cal managed care6.39%19 hoursMedian posted as 19 hours
Molina Healthcare of California (Medi-Cal)Medi-Cal managed care2.0%24 hoursMedian posted in whole days

1 day

median time from a standard prior authorization request to the decision in Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care in 2025, in KFF's analysis

In KFF's analysis of the largest insurers' 2025 reports, the median time from a standard prior authorization request to the decision was 1 day in Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care and 0.9 days in the federally facilitated Marketplace.

Source: KFF, Prior Authorization Metrics Provide New Insights into Insurer Practices, but Gaps Remain (August 13, 2026).

KentAppliedkentapplied.com/facts/prior-auth-median-standard-decision-1-day-2025

What changes in the next reports?

CMS has already asked for some of the missing pieces in the reports for 2026, which are due March 31, 2027. Its July 2026 template asks plans to report "both counts and percentages," and says all turnaround times "must include explicit time units (hours or calendar days)."

In April 2026, CMS proposed going further. The proposal would have plans report "a numeric count for each of those metrics (in addition to the percentages)," and it says the denominator "should be the total number of prior authorization requests" for every metric except appeals, where it "should be the total number of decided appeals." If CMS finalizes it, the new metrics would apply from the date the final rule takes effect and be reported the following year.

The 2024 rule also requires plans to run a Prior Authorization API, a connection through which a provider's systems can send a request and receive the plan's decision, beginning January 1, 2027, according to CMS's fact sheet.

7 days

calendar days a Medicare Advantage or Medicaid plan has to decide a standard prior authorization request from 2026

Since January 1, 2026, Medicare Advantage organizations and Medicaid and CHIP programs and their managed care plans must decide standard prior authorization requests within seven calendar days and expedited requests within 72 hours, under CMS's 2024 rule.

Source: CMS, fact sheet on the Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule (CMS-0057-F).

KentAppliedkentapplied.com/facts/prior-auth-standard-decisions-7-days-2026

What can a medical group or hospital do with these reports?

The rule makes each plan post its report on its own website, so start with the reports of the plans your patients use, which the explorer below lists by county, and read each one's numbers next to how it counted them. Physicians complete an average of 40 prior authorizations a week, which take 13 hours of physician and staff time, the AMA's 2025 survey of 1,000 practicing physicians found.

40

prior authorizations a week, on average, per physician

Physicians complete an average of 40 prior authorizations a week, which take 13 hours of physician and staff time, the AMA's 2025 survey of 1,000 physicians found.

Source: AMA survey: Prior authorization reform pledge falls short with physicians.

KentAppliedkentapplied.com/facts/physicians-40-prior-authorizations-a-week-2025

Before comparing two plans, check that both reports give counts, say how they treat partly approved requests and divide appeals by appeals, as the explorer below shows for each report. When the 2026 reports arrive, compare each plan with its own 2025 report too, because the 2026 decisions were made under the seven-day limit.

If your group is weighing software that drafts or submits prior authorization requests, ask for evidence. One figure that circulates, that automated prior authorization cuts processing time by 60%, traces to no source that could be found, as where healthcare AI has proof shows. AI Vendor Evaluation tests each vendor on your shortlist on cases from your own organization, with its three-year cost and how it would handle your data in writing. It takes two weeks and costs $7,500–9,500, and how to score an AI vendor before the demo sets out the steps.

Find a plan's 2025 prior authorization report

Every report in the dataset, as the plan posted it, with how it counts. The list has 67 entries, and 60 of them have a 2025 report.

67 entries: the 59 plan reports, the state's report for Medi-Cal fee-for-service, and 7 plans in scope with no report we could find.

Download every report (CSV, CC BY 4.0)

Every report as a table
Every 2025 prior authorization report in the dataset, as posted
ReportStandard requests deniedExpedited requests deniedMedian time, standardIn the comparison
Medicare Advantage
Aetna H05232.39%2.94%0 day(s)Yes
Aetna H49822.04%2.79%0 day(s)Yes
Aetna H530916.34%24.73%0 day(s)Yes
Aetna H55217.86%10.87%0 day(s)No
Aetna H55226.97%10.95%0 day(s)No
Alignment Health Plan H38152.14% (17,933)2.87% (3,787)0.50 daysYes
Alignment Health Plan H49612.88% (146)1.96% (32)3.00 daysYes
Alignment Health Plan H88322.89% (117)2.12% (34)0.75 daysYes
Anthem Blue Cross H05441.6%1.1%1Yes
Anthem Blue Cross H40365.2%5.1%1No
Anthem Blue Cross H41612.2%1.9%1Yes
Anthem Blue Cross H44710.9%1.7%1Yes
Anthem Blue Cross H47049.2%7.6%1Yes
Anthem Blue Cross H85525.0%2.0%1Yes
Blue Shield of California H05042% (6,934)2% (1,442)0 (calendar days)Yes
Blue Shield of California H28191% (1,617)3% (383)0 (calendar days)Yes
Blue Shield of California H493712% (461)2% (13)3 (calendar days)Yes
Blue Shield of California H59282% (1,010)2% (152)0 (calendar days)Yes
CalOptima Health H54331.38% (1,311)1.90% (257)0.0 daysYes
Central Health Plan of California H56491%1%0 (days)Yes
Community Health Group H4733Not reported separately; the plan posts Medi-Cal and all-business figures only.
Health Plan of San Mateo H6019No 2025 report found on the plan's own site.
Humana H52166.87% (291,089)10.20% (10,957)0 day(s)No
Humana H55257.60% (21,438)11.86% (782)0 day(s)No
Humana H56195.09% (63,115)3.72% (3,816)0 day(s)No
Inland Empire Health Plan H88942% (7,971)3% (2,163)1.04 DaysNo
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Northern California)10.53% (15,214)7.46% (5,123)0 Days 22 HoursYes
Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California)19.48% (27,992)3.65% (2,085)0 Days 2 HoursYes
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Northern California)11.33% (4,486)8.46% (1,320)0 Days 21 HoursYes
Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Southern California)10.95% (3,706)2.80% (223)0 Days 2 HoursYes
L.A. Care Health Plan H12241.03% (2,935)2.06% (639)not postedYes
Molina Healthcare of California H30382%4%0 (days)Yes
Molina Healthcare of California H58102%4%0 (days)Yes
Santa Clara Family Health Plan H40459.29% (1,219)6.34% (460)6.42 (days)No
SCAN Health Plan (Medicare Advantage)1.85% (38,284)2.21% (6,044)1 dayYes
UnitedHealthcare H029419.8% (17,985), posted as "Initial Not Approved"14.7% (836), posted as "Initial Not Approved"1.9 daysNo
UnitedHealthcare H05431.8% (27,521), posted as "Initial Not Approved"2.7% (5,792), posted as "Initial Not Approved"2.4 daysNo
UnitedHealthcare H200123.4% (434,745), posted as "Initial Not Approved"11.5% (8,635), posted as "Initial Not Approved"1.8 daysNo
Wellcare By Health Net H05621.94% (3,584)2.87% (716)1 daysYes
Wellcare By Health Net H35611.98% (5,737)3.03% (1,212)1 daysYes
Wellcare of California H5087No 2025 report found on the plan's own site.
Medi-Cal managed care
Alameda Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal)3.0% (3,485)4.1% (1,650)1.4 calendar daysYes
Anthem Blue Cross (Medi-Cal)2.6%8.1%1Yes
Blue Shield of California Promise Health Plan (Medi-Cal)1% (6,003)1% (1,207)1 (calendar days)Yes
CalOptima Health (Medi-Cal)1.72% (16,568)3.11% (4,373)0.00 daysYes
CalViva Health (Medi-Cal)6.34% (19,665)5.10% (2,166)0 daysYes
CenCal Health (Medi-Cal)0.54% (308); a further 0.08% (47) "Modified"0.55% (21); a further 0.10% (4) "Modified"1 DayNo
Central California Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal)1.55% (8029)0.29% (88)0 (day)Yes
Community Health Group (Medi-Cal)0.64%1.96%0.0007 daysYes
Community Health Plan of Imperial Valley (Medi-Cal)7.57% (4,347)3.18% (444)1 daysYes
Contra Costa Health Plan (Medi-Cal)10.89% (6,741)11.53% (885)1.88 (days)No
Gold Coast Health Plan (Medi-Cal)2% (6,245)2% (1,032)4 daysYes
Health Net (Medi-Cal)2.45% (75,814)4.32% (17,049)0 daysYes
Health Plan of San Joaquin (Medi-Cal)5.03%4.63%6.98 (days)Yes
Health Plan of San Mateo (Medi-Cal)No 2025 report found on the plan's own site.
Inland Empire Health Plan (Medi-Cal)1% (32,642)1% (6,393)0.57 DaysNo
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Northern California)8.95% (2,235)6.45% (618)0 Days 21 HoursYes
Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Southern California)6.39% (3,622)2.58% (199)0 Days 19 HoursYes
Kern Family Health Care (Medi-Cal)No 2025 report found on the plan's own site.
L.A. Care Health Plan (Medi-Cal)1.86% (40,033)3.78% (13,245)not postedYes
Molina Healthcare of California (Medi-Cal)2%2%1 (days)Yes
Mountain Valley Health Plan (Medi-Cal)No separate report found; an affiliated plan's report may or may not include it.
Partnership HealthPlan of California (Medi-Cal)22.34% (76,228), of which 7.21% (24,607) "related to medical necessity review" and 15.13% (51,621) "related to administrative denials"19.16% (15,732), of which 9.21% (7,558) medical necessity and 9.96% (8,174) administrative5 daysNo
San Francisco Health Plan (Medi-Cal)1.98% (1,242) "denied, either fully or partially"2.56% (398) "denied, either fully or partially"6.04 calendar daysNo
Santa Clara Family Health Plan (Medi-Cal)4.01% (7,294)6.57% (1,717)5.25 (days)No
SCAN Health Plan (Medi-Cal)Not reported separately; the plan posts one report with no separate Medi-Cal figures.
Medi-Cal fee-for-service
DHCS, Medi-Cal fee-for-service28% (22,404)not posted2 (calendar days, standard and expedited together)No

How we did this

The dataset covers every Medi-Cal managed care plan and the Medicare Advantage contracts of the largest companies in California. For Medicare Advantage, it holds every California contract with at least 1,000 members in December 2025 from the ten parent companies that each had at least 2.5% of the state's Medicare Advantage members, the share KFF used as its cutoff nationally, plus the Medicare contracts of the Medi-Cal plans: 40 contracts in all. Members come from CMS's enrollment file for December 2025, with all-inclusive care programs for older adults (PACE) left out. For Medi-Cal, it holds all 24 managed care plans in the state's enrollment report for December 2025, leaving out dental plans, PACE, special projects and the case management program, plus the state's fee-for-service report. The explorer's county filter lists a contract or plan in each county where it had members in December 2025, from the same two files, which leave out the smallest counts.

The numbers in each report are copied exactly as posted, with the plan's wording, units and rounding, from the copy on the plan's site on October 17, 2026. Internet Archive copies stood in for two pages whose sites refuse automated reads: the state's page that links its fee-for-service report (a copy from July 10, 2026) and Contra Costa Health Plan's metrics page (a copy from July 11, 2026).

Every report then got plain labels for how it counts: whether it gives counts, how it treats partly approved requests, whether its denials include administrative ones, what its appeal and extension shares are out of, and the unit of its times. Where a report disagrees with itself, such as a table against its own summary sentence, the explorer's notes for that report say where. A report passes the like-for-like test, and enters a comparison, only when it counts as posted, its approved and denied shares account for every standard request, and it doesn't state a different way of counting partial approvals or administrative denials. Medicare Advantage contracts where California held under half of the members stay in the explorer and the download but out of the comparisons. UnitedHealthcare's reports are the only ones here that say whether they include requests handled by delegates: they include requests submitted to capitated-delegated providers and to behavioral health, physical health and dental delegates. None of the other reports say either way.

Where a plan posted counts, Kent Applied worked out its shares the way CMS's July 2026 template expects: approvals and denials out of all requests of that type, approvals after an extension out of all requests, and approvals after appeal out of appeals. Times are turned into hours only when the plan gave a unit, and medians posted in whole days count as 24 hours a day. Medians posted as a whole 0 days, and times with no unit, stay as posted. A median posted with decimals, as 0.0 or 0.00 days, counts as 0 hours, because its decimals put it under 1.2 hours.

Regional reports for one contract stay as separate rows, as the plan posted them. The only member-weighted figures are the two set beside KFF's national averages, one for each program, and they cover only the comparable reports. They weight each report by its California members in December 2025, and a contract reported in two regional parts is split by each part's share of the standard requests. No share or rate adds Medicare Advantage and Medi-Cal together. The line in the dot chart marks the middle report of each program, and rank correlations are worked out within each program.

The data is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: every report, one row each, and California enrollment by what was posted.

Questions and answers

Do these reports cover Covered California plans?

No. The federal rule's marketplace sections cover only issuers on the federally facilitated exchanges, and California runs its own exchange, so Covered California plans did not have to post these reports.

Can a Medicare Advantage contract be compared with a Medi-Cal plan?

Not fairly. KFF warns that case mix, meaning how sick members are, and service mix, meaning which services they use, "likely vary substantially between lines of business." This report compares reports only within each program.

Why do two plans' denial shares differ so much?

Part of the gap is how each plan counted. A plan that counts duplicate requests as denials, or counts a partly approved request as denied, posts a higher share than a plan that does neither, even if the two made the same decisions. The explorer shows how each report counted.

When do the next reports come out?

The 2026 reports are due March 31, 2027. They will be the first to cover a full year under the seven-day limit for standard requests.

Download the data

Free to share and reuse with credit to Kent Applied, under the CC BY 4.0 license. How the data was made is in How we did this.

Related service

Related articles

More on payment and policy: 25 charts and 38 sourced facts.

Insights by email

Does this look like your organization?

Book a 20-minute call with Tyler to talk through your version of this problem and what fixing it would cost.

Prefer to skip the call? Get a written proposal