Comparable reports show no clear link between denying more and deciding more slowly
Each dot is one plan's 2025 report, colored by program. It shows the share of standard (non-urgent) prior authorization requests the plan denied and its median hours from request to decision, for the reports that pass a basic like-for-like test and gave their median in a unit. The link is measured within each program
Show the numbers as a table
| Item | Group | Share of standard requests denied | Median hours from request to decision | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alignment Health Plan H3815 | Medicare Advantage | 2.14% | 12 hours | Median posted as 0.50 days |
| Alignment Health Plan H4961 | Medicare Advantage | 2.88% | 72 hours | Median posted as 3.00 days |
| Alignment Health Plan H8832 | Medicare Advantage | 2.89% | 18 hours | Median posted as 0.75 days |
| Blue Shield of California H4937 | Medicare Advantage | 12.04% | 72 hours | Median posted in whole days |
| CalOptima Health H5433 | Medicare Advantage | 1.38% | 0 hours | Median posted as 0.0 days |
| Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Northern California) | Medicare Advantage | 10.53% | 22 hours | Median posted as 22 hours |
| Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California) | Medicare Advantage | 19.48% | 2 hours | Median posted as 2 hours |
| Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Northern California) | Medicare Advantage | 11.33% | 21 hours | Median posted as 21 hours |
| Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Southern California) | Medicare Advantage | 10.95% | 2 hours | Median posted as 2 hours |
| SCAN Health Plan (Medicare Advantage) | Medicare Advantage | 1.85% | 24 hours | Median posted in whole days |
| Wellcare By Health Net H0562 | Medicare Advantage | 1.94% | 24 hours | Median posted in whole days |
| Wellcare By Health Net H3561 | Medicare Advantage | 1.98% | 24 hours | Median posted in whole days |
| Alameda Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 2.97% | 33.6 hours | Median posted as 1.4 days |
| Blue Shield of California Promise Health Plan (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 0.67% | 24 hours | Median posted in whole days |
| CalOptima Health (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 1.72% | 0 hours | Median posted as 0.00 days |
| Community Health Group (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 0.64% | 0.02 hours | Median posted as 0.0007 days |
| Community Health Plan of Imperial Valley (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 7.57% | 24 hours | Median posted in whole days |
| Gold Coast Health Plan (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 1.96% | 96 hours | Median posted in whole days |
| Health Plan of San Joaquin (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 5.03% | 167.52 hours | Median posted as 6.98 days |
| Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Northern California) | Medi-Cal managed care | 8.95% | 21 hours | Median posted as 21 hours |
| Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Southern California) | Medi-Cal managed care | 6.39% | 19 hours | Median posted as 19 hours |
| Molina Healthcare of California (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 2.0% | 24 hours | Median posted in whole days |
About the data
- Sources
- Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset)Download: prior-auth-reports-california-2025.csv
- CMS, fact sheet on the Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule (CMS-0057-F), January 17, 2024 (opens in a new tab)Section on prior authorization decision time frames
- Method
- Times are converted to hours only when the plan gave a unit. Medians posted as a whole 0 days, and times posted with no unit, are left out, because they cannot be turned into hours. A median posted with decimals, as 0.0 or 0.00 days, stays and is plotted at 0 hours, because its decimals put it under 1.2 hours. Medians posted in whole days are shown at 24 hours a day. The dashed line marks 7 calendar days, the limit for standard decisions from 2026.
- Published
Free to share and embed with credit to Kent Applied (CC BY 4.0). The source data keeps its own terms.
Related charts
- From research
Urgent requests were denied more often than standard ones at 9 of 16 Medicare Advantage reports
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); CMS, Prior Authorization Metrics Reporting: Overview and Template (July 2026) - From research
Most comparable California plan reports denied 3% or less of standard requests in 2025
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); CMS, Prior Authorization Metrics Reporting: Overview and Template (July 2026) - From research
Few 2025 reports say how they counted partial approvals or administrative denials
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); eCFR, 42 CFR 422.122(c) and 438.210(f) - From research
Posted reports cover 95% of California Medicare Advantage and 96% of Medi-Cal plan members
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); CMS, MA Enrollment by State/County/Contract, December 2025 (abridged); DHCS, Medi-Cal Managed Care Enrollment Report
Book a 20-minute call
Tyler Kent can measure a question like this one in your own data. Start with a short call.
Prefer to skip the call? Get a written proposal
Or email tyler@kentapplied.com.