Most comparable California plan reports denied 3% or less of standard requests in 2025
Share of standard (non-urgent) prior authorization requests denied in 2025, one dot per report, among the reports that pass a basic like-for-like test: Medicare Advantage contracts mostly in California, and Medi-Cal managed care plans
Show the numbers as a table
| Item | Group | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anthem Blue Cross H4471 | Medicare Advantage | 0.9% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Central Health Plan of California H5649 | Medicare Advantage | 1.0% | Posted as a percentage only |
| L.A. Care Health Plan H1224 | Medicare Advantage | 1.03% | 2,935 of 284,406 standard requests |
| Blue Shield of California H2819 | Medicare Advantage | 1.31% | 1,617 of 122,926 standard requests |
| CalOptima Health H5433 | Medicare Advantage | 1.38% | 1,311 of 94,832 standard requests |
| Blue Shield of California H5928 | Medicare Advantage | 1.50% | 1,010 of 67,137 standard requests |
| Blue Shield of California H0504 | Medicare Advantage | 1.54% | 6,934 of 451,021 standard requests |
| Anthem Blue Cross H0544 | Medicare Advantage | 1.6% | Posted as a percentage only |
| SCAN Health Plan (Medicare Advantage) | Medicare Advantage | 1.85% | 38,284 of 2,070,236 standard requests |
| Wellcare By Health Net H0562 | Medicare Advantage | 1.94% | 3,584 of 184,541 standard requests |
| Wellcare By Health Net H3561 | Medicare Advantage | 1.98% | 5,737 of 290,257 standard requests |
| Molina Healthcare of California H3038 | Medicare Advantage | 2.0% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Molina Healthcare of California H5810 | Medicare Advantage | 2.0% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Aetna H4982 | Medicare Advantage | 2.04% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Alignment Health Plan H3815 | Medicare Advantage | 2.14% | 17,933 of 837,729 standard requests |
| Anthem Blue Cross H4161 | Medicare Advantage | 2.2% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Aetna H0523 | Medicare Advantage | 2.39% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Alignment Health Plan H4961 | Medicare Advantage | 2.88% | 146 of 5,063 standard requests |
| Alignment Health Plan H8832 | Medicare Advantage | 2.89% | 117 of 4,044 standard requests |
| Anthem Blue Cross H8552 | Medicare Advantage | 5.0% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Anthem Blue Cross H4704 | Medicare Advantage | 9.2% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Northern California) | Medicare Advantage | 10.53% | 15,214 of 144,514 standard requests |
| Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Southern California) | Medicare Advantage | 10.95% | 3,706 of 33,855 standard requests |
| Kaiser Permanente H8794 (Northern California) | Medicare Advantage | 11.33% | 4,486 of 39,581 standard requests |
| Blue Shield of California H4937 | Medicare Advantage | 12.04% | 461 of 3,829 standard requests |
| Aetna H5309 | Medicare Advantage | 16.34% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Kaiser Permanente H0524 (Southern California) | Medicare Advantage | 19.48% | 27,992 of 143,690 standard requests |
| Community Health Group (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 0.64% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Blue Shield of California Promise Health Plan (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 0.67% | 6,003 of 892,009 standard requests |
| Central California Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 1.55% | 8,029 of 518,170 standard requests |
| CalOptima Health (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 1.72% | 16,568 of 965,191 standard requests |
| L.A. Care Health Plan (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 1.86% | 40,033 of 2,152,883 standard requests |
| Gold Coast Health Plan (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 1.96% | 6,245 of 319,137 standard requests |
| Molina Healthcare of California (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 2.0% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Health Net (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 2.45% | 75,814 of 3,096,168 standard requests |
| Anthem Blue Cross (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 2.6% | Posted as a percentage only |
| Alameda Alliance for Health (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 2.97% | 3,485 of 117,421 standard requests |
| Health Plan of San Joaquin (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 5.03% | Posted as a percentage only |
| CalViva Health (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 6.34% | 19,665 of 310,319 standard requests |
| Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Southern California) | Medi-Cal managed care | 6.39% | 3,622 of 56,689 standard requests |
| Community Health Plan of Imperial Valley (Medi-Cal) | Medi-Cal managed care | 7.57% | 4,347 of 57,406 standard requests |
| Kaiser Permanente (Medi-Cal, Northern California) | Medi-Cal managed care | 8.95% | 2,235 of 24,982 standard requests |
About the data
- Sources
- Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset)Download: prior-auth-reports-california-2025.csv
- CMS, Prior Authorization Metrics Reporting: Overview and Template (July 2026) (opens in a new tab)Template tables, pp. 5 to 6
- Method
- A report is in the chart when it passes a basic like-for-like test: it was posted on the site of the plan or its parent company, or, for two Medi-Cal plans, under the plan's own name on Health Net's site, its approved and denied shares account for every standard request, and it does not say that it counts partly approved requests or administrative denials differently from the others. Reports that say nothing on those points are treated as alike. Medicare Advantage contracts with under half of their members in California are left out. Where a plan posted counts, Kent Applied divided the denials by the standard requests, as CMS's July 2026 template expects; otherwise the posted percentage is used. The line in each row marks the middle report of that row.
- Published
Free to share and embed with credit to Kent Applied (CC BY 4.0). The source data keeps its own terms.
Related charts
- From research
Urgent requests were denied more often than standard ones at 9 of 16 Medicare Advantage reports
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); CMS, Prior Authorization Metrics Reporting: Overview and Template (July 2026) - From research
Few 2025 reports say how they counted partial approvals or administrative denials
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); eCFR, 42 CFR 422.122(c) and 438.210(f) - From research
Posted reports cover 95% of California Medicare Advantage and 96% of Medi-Cal plan members
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); CMS, MA Enrollment by State/County/Contract, December 2025 (abridged); DHCS, Medi-Cal Managed Care Enrollment Report - From research
Comparable reports show no clear link between denying more and deciding more slowly
Kent Applied, 2025 prior authorization reports of plans serving California (dataset); CMS, fact sheet on the Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule (CMS-0057-F), January 17, 2024
Book a 20-minute call
Tyler Kent can measure a question like this one in your own data. Start with a short call.
Prefer to skip the call? Get a written proposal
Or email tyler@kentapplied.com.